You’re going to enjoy Opening Manassas. Two authors, Bill Bakus, writing and analyzing the Confederate operations, decisions, and the thoughts of the boots on the ground perspective and Lance J. Herdegen, analyzing the Union operations etc. The bibliography is ample and end notes amplify the basis of their analysis. The only item they don’t address is luck and each side appears to have a bit of it.
An interesting anecdote on the Union formation was the suspicion held by Northern soldiers from the North East United States against the Westerners from Wisconsin and Indiana. Wisconsin State troops wore gray uniforms rather than blue and they had to be outfitted with proper Union uniforms before joining the Union formation. And how did the Iron Brigade get its name? In most histories describing where the Iron Brigade fought the name is prominent but to learn the formations that compose the brigade, not so much and there is more than one attempt to clarify when it became known as the Iron brigade. So, what was the origin of the name and how about General “Stonewall”Jackson? It’s pretty much common knowledge that Stonewall had a unique leadership style. Abrasive, distant, and secretive to the peril of his troops but they loved him. Bill Bakus makes the point that he was a better commander than a subordinate. You can judge. The answers will be revealed to your satisfaction, maybe. Brawner’s Farm is not a battle that immediately comes to mind when addressing Manassas. The maps provide ample detail on the terrain and disposition of the formations in the engagement. And, the authors offer short anecdotes on other leaders in the contest, many of which have little mention in other accounts of the challenges experienced in a battle.
Opening Manassas is well written and provides a compelling picture of the challenges leaders and troops experience in battle. You will enjoy it.
Review written by Arley McCormick
