Search

Tennessee Valley Civil War Round Table

Education and Preservation

Category

Book Review

Opening Manassas: The Iron Brigade, Stonewall Jackson, and the Battle of Brawner’s Farm, August 28, 1862

You’re going to enjoy Opening Manassas. Two authors, Bill Bakus, writing and analyzing the Confederate operations, decisions, and the thoughts of the boots on the ground perspective and Lance J. Herdegen, analyzing the Union operations etc. The bibliography is ample and end notes amplify the basis of their analysis. The only item they don’t address is luck and each side appears to have a bit of it.
An interesting anecdote on the Union formation was the suspicion held by Northern soldiers from the North East United States against the Westerners from Wisconsin and Indiana. Wisconsin State troops wore gray uniforms rather than blue and they had to be outfitted with proper Union uniforms before joining the Union formation. And how did the Iron Brigade get its name? In most histories describing where the Iron Brigade fought the name is prominent but to learn the formations that compose the brigade, not so much and there is more than one attempt to clarify when it became known as the Iron brigade. So, what was the origin of the name and how about General “Stonewall”Jackson? It’s pretty much common knowledge that Stonewall had a unique leadership style. Abrasive, distant, and secretive to the peril of his troops but they loved him. Bill Bakus makes the point that he was a better commander than a subordinate. You can judge. The answers will be revealed to your satisfaction, maybe. Brawner’s Farm is not a battle that immediately comes to mind when addressing Manassas. The maps provide ample detail on the terrain and disposition of the formations in the engagement. And, the authors offer short anecdotes on other leaders in the contest, many of which have little mention in other accounts of the challenges experienced in a battle.
Opening Manassas is well written and provides a compelling picture of the challenges leaders and troops experience in battle. You will enjoy it.

Review written by Arley McCormick

The Blood Tinted Waters of the Shenandoah, the 1864 Valley Campaign’s Battle of Cool Spring, July 17-18, 1864

Book reviewed by Arley McCormick, Tennessee Valley Civil War Round Table

The Blood

John Reynolds’ I Corps at Gettysburg on July 1, 1863

Book review by Arley McCormick, Tennessee Valley Civil War Round Table.

John Reynolds

Wilson’s Raid, The Final Blow to the Confederacy

In large part because the major Civil War campaigns occurring within Alabama’s borders took place near the end of the war, there has long been a tendency to overlook them by historians. We have remained ignorant of some of the most compelling actions of the war as a result. Had the largest cavalry force mounted during the war swept through one of the Confederacy’s most important industrial states and wreaked a swath of havoc and destruction for some 200 miles in 1862, for example, I would think we might remember as something more than a footnote in the story of the conflict. Yet that is exactly what happened in the spring of 1865 in Alabama in the form of a devastating raid by Gen. James H. Wilson, and that is exactly how we have unfortunately often remembered the affair.

   Wilson’s Raid deserves better, for it involves an incredible story and rendered a final, crippling blow to the Confederacy’s ability to make war with unprecedented speed and precision. In the course of just over two weeks, Wilson cut through the heart of northern and central Alabama, beginning at the banks of the Tennessee River and exiting the state at the Chattahoochee at the border city of Columbus, Georgia. Along the way he and his men defeated two armies, rendered useless numerous iron-making facilities (and burned no few private homes in the process), captured and destroyed two of the South’s largest military-industrial complexes, secured the surrender of the first capital of the Confederacy, dismantled a state university, and handed Nathan Bedford Forrest one of his very few whippings. In the days after the fighting concluded, Wilson’s men would go on to become involved in the capture of Confederate president Jefferson Davis. To say the raid was eventful and is worthy of remembrance is an understatement.

   There have been attempts to chronicle the raid, most of them a chapter or two in length and presented as part of a series of studies of several end-of-war campaigns, such as Noah Trudeau’s Out of the Storm: The End of the Civil War, April-June, 1865. The most notable study of the raid in its own right is James Pickett Jones’ Yankee Blitzkrieg: Wilson’s Raid Through Alabama and Georgia, a book that by its very title communicates the fact that Wilson’s tactics presaged the advent of what we recognize as modern mechanized cavalry tactics but appeared many years ago. Here now, is retired businessman Russell Blount’s effort at tracing Wilson’s footprints, in the form of Wilson’s Raid: Final Blow to the Confederacy. As we have detailed previously in this blog, Blount is already an accomplished author (Besieged: Mobile 1865) and has a demonstrated interest in the often-overlooked last days of the war.

   Blount tells a rollicking tale in the fast-moving book, providing an overview of military operations but at the same time allowing space to incorporate civilian perspectives in what promises to be an essential introduction to the topic for the next generation. He follows Wilson’s path and lays out his strategy, providing us with some of the best summaries of the fighting that occurred at places such as Selma and Columbus that one is likely to read and bringing the communities touched by the campaign to life. These accounts along with his use of accounts of the raid from a variety of civilians shows a command of the available resources on the topic. His prose is smooth, his pace just right, and the key players in the story he tells emerge as real people. Wilson’s Raid is a quick read but one that thoroughly treats it subject. If you have an interest in Alabama or Civil War history, this book is definitely worth your time.

The Great Battle Never Fought: The Mine Run Campaign, November 26 December 2, 1863

MineRun

Review by John Scales

Let Us Die Like Men, The Battle of Franklin, November 30, 1864

Let Us Die Like Men

Review by John Scales

The Most Desperate Acts of Gallantry: George A. Custer in the Civil War

Hellmira: The Union’s Most Infamous Civil War Prison Camp – Elmira, N.Y.

Hellmira

Review by Ed Kennedy

America’s Buried History, Landmines in the Civil War

America's Buried History,

Review by Emil Posey

Seceding From Secession; The Civil War, Politics, and the Creation of West Virginia

Seceding From Secession

Review by Arley McCormick

The Petersburg Regiment in the Civil War, A History of the 12th Virginia Infantry from John Brown’s Hanging to Appomattox 1859-1865

Caught in the Maelstrom, The Indian Nations in the Civil War 1861-1865

Book Caught in the Maelstrom

Review by Arley McCormick

Lincoln Takes Command – The Campaign to Seize Norfolk and the Destruction of the CSS Virginia

Book Lincoln Takes Command

Review by Ricardo Jaramillo

Lee is Trapped and Must be Taken: Eleven Fateful Days after Gettysburg

Book - Lee is Trapped and Must be Taken

 

Review by John Scales

North by South, The Two Lives of Richard James Arnold

North by South

Review by Emil Posey

Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑